This
is collection of articles about apnea and the effect on
the body
Andersson,
J P A, Biasoletto-Tjellström, G, and Schagatay, E K A
Effects
of the human diving response on the alveolar gas
exchange during apnea. In manuscript, 2002.
Andersson, J P A, Linér, M H, Fredsted, A, and
Schagatay, E K A
Alveolar gas exchange and cardiovascular responses
during apneas in exercising humans. In manuscript, 2002.
Schagatay,
E, and van Kampen, M
Apneic
snout immersion in trained pigs elicits a "diving
response". Advances in Experimental Medicine and
Biology 393:73-76, 1995.
Schagatay,
E, van Kampen, M, and Andersson, J
Effects
of repeated apneas on apneic time and diving response in
non-divers. Undersea and Hyperbaric Medicine 26:143-149,
1999.
Abstract
Human
breath-hold divers usually perform a series of dives
with short intervals. Repeated apneas prolong apneic
time, and an accentuated diving response has been
suggested to be the cause. The aim of this study was to
investigate the effect of repeated apneas on apneic time
and diving response in humans. Forty-one subjects
performed a series of five apneas with face immersion in
water of 10 degrees Centigrade, separated by 2-min
intervals. Apneas were performed at rest and to
individual maximal duration. Heart rate, mean arterial
pressure, skin capillary blood flow, and respiratory
movements were recorded. Thirty-eight of the subjects
were used for analysis of cardiovascular parameters, and
in 23 subjects the physiological breaking point could be
detected by the involuntary breathing movements. Heart
rate reduction and blood pressure increase were most
prominent during the first apneic face immersion, while
skin capillary blood flow reduction was most intense in
the second apneic face immersion. Blood pressure and
skin capillary blood flow during recovery from apneic
episodes also changed throughout the series. Repetition
increased apneic time by 55% and postponed the
occurrence of involuntary breathing movements by 27% in
subjects passing the physiological breaking point. We
conclude that both physiologic factors, associated with
the accumulation of CO2, and psychologic factors,
related to the capacity to withstand the respiratory
drive, contribute to the prolongation of apneic time
whereas an increased diving response does not contribute.
Key
words: diving reflex, bradycardia, vasoconstriction,
arterial blood pressure, breath-holding time, short-term
training.
Holm, B, Schagatay, E, and Andersson, J
A
possible physiological role of the face as a
thermosensor in an ancient water ape and in present day
humans. Perpectives in Human Biology 4:41-46, 1999.
Schagatay,
E, and Andersson, J
Diving
response and apneic time in humans. Undersea and
Hyperbaric Medicine 25:13-19, 1998.
Abstract
The
aim of this study was to compare apneic time with the
human diving response, defined as heart rate (HR)
reduction and reduced skin blood flow, in groups with
varying degrees of breath-hold diving experience. Apneic
time and HR reduction at apneas in air and apneas with
face immersion in cold water were thus recorded in nine
groups. Skin capillary blood flow was recorded in six of
the groups. All subjects received the same information
on maximizing apneic duration, and no information about
their progress during the apneas. The longest apneas and
the most pronounced cardiovascular adjustments were
found in the young, trained divers. It was found that
apneic time was significantly correlated to HR reduction
among the nine groups (r = 0.94, P < 0.001), and to
skin capillary blood flow reduction among the six groups
where the parameter was measured (r = 0.82, P <
0.05). The correlation between HR reduction and skin
capillary blood flow reduction was also significant (r =
0.85, P < 0.05). When the difference in HR reduction
and apneic time between apneas in air and apneas with
face immersion were compared in the nine groups, it was
found that all groups reacted with a more pronounced HR
reduction during apneas with face immersion. All groups
without prior breath-hold diving experience were found
to perform shorter apneas with face immersion than
apneas in air, or apneas of the same duration in both
conditions, which has been reported in other studies.
However, in all groups with diving experience, the
apneic time was prolonged during apneas with face
immersion. The results of this study suggest an
oxygen-conserving effect of the diving response in
trained apneic divers.
Key
words: breath-hold, face immersion, bradycardia,
vasoconstriction, oxygen conservation.
Andersson,
J, and Schagatay, E
Arterial
oxygen desaturation during apnea in humans. Undersea and
Hyperbaric Medicine 25:21-25, 1998b.
Abstract
We
studied the effect of the human diving response, defined
as bradycardia and reduced peripheral blood flow, on
arterial hemoglobin desaturation. We induced a diving
response of different magnitudes by using apnea in air
and apnea with face immersion. Each of 21 subjects
performed five apneas in air and five apneas with face
immersion in 10 degrees Centigrade water. Periods of
apnea in both conditions were of the same duration in
any individual subject (average: 126.4 s) and the order
of air and water was equally distributed among subjects.
Heart rate, skin capillary blood flow, arterial blood
pressure, arterial hemoglobin oxygen saturation during
apneas, and end-tidal fractions of CO2 after apneas were
recorded with non-invasive methods. The bradycardia and
capillary blood flow reduction during apnea in air (7.8
and 37.7% change from control, respectively) were
significantly potentiated by face immersion (13.6 and
55.9%, respectively). Arterial hemoglobin desaturated
more during apnea in air (2.7%) compared to during apnea
with face immersion (1.4%). We conclude that the
potentiation of the human diving response with face
immersion in cold water leads to a smaller decrease in
arterial hemoglobin saturation, which may reflect an
oxygen-conserving effect.
Key
words: breath-holding, face immersion, bradycardia,
vasoconstriction, diving response, oxygen saturation.
Holm, B, Schagatay, E, Kobayashi, T, Masuda, A, Ohdaira,
T, and Honda, Y
Cardiovascular
change in elderly male breath-hold divers (Ama) and
their socio-economical background at Chikura in Japan.
Applied Human Science 17:181-187, 1998.
Gennser,
M., E. Schagatay, J. Andersson, B. Lagercrantz, D.
Benoni, and H. Örnhagen. (1999) Cardiorespiratory
effects of apnoeic dives and free ascents in two classes
of divers. In: Shupak, A., R. Lincoln, and Y. Grossman
(eds.) XXV Annual Scientific Meeting of the European
Underwater and Baromedical Society, Haifa and Eilat,
Israel: 228-231.
Örnhagen,
H., E. Schagatay, J. Andersson, E. Bergsten, P.
Gustafsson, and S. Sandström. (1998) Mechanisms of
“buccal pumping” (“lung packing”) and its
pulmonary effects. In: Gennser, M. (ed.) XXIV Annual
Scientific Meeting of the European Underwater and
Baromedical Society. National Defence Research
Establishment, Stockholm, Sweden. FOA Report: FOA-B--98-00342--721--SE:
80-83.
Andersson,
J., and E. Schagatay. (1998) Effects of the human diving
response on oxygen consumption. In: Gennser, M. (ed.)
XXIV Annual Scientific Meeting of the European
Underwater and Baromedical Society. National Defence
Research Establishment, Stockholm, Sweden. FOA Report:
FOA-B--98-00342--721--SE: 84-87.
INTRODUCTION
During diving, marine mammals redistribute blood flow
and reduce heart rate by the “diving response”. This
response is part of their complex adaptations to sustain
apnoea. The diving response in some marine mammals is
considered to reduce the rate of oxygen consumption. A
reduced rate of oxygen consumption has been observed in
some species as a lower post-dive oxygen uptake compared
to the pre-dive uptake. A diving response similar to
that found in diving mammals and birds is induced when
humans are breath-holding. The human diving response is
enhanced during breath-hold diving when, in addition to
the apnoea, the upper part of the face is immersed (4).
In humans, the most pronounced effects are a bradycardia
and a selective vasoconstriction, resulting in a
redistribution of the blood flow towards the
hypoxia-sensitive organs (e.g. the heart and brain). The
effect of the human diving response on the rate of
oxygen consumption has been a matter of debate, some
results suggesting an effect while others do not. In
studies on several groups of subjects with varying
degrees of breath-hold diving experience we have found
that the most experienced subjects (i.e., native
breath-hold divers and trained under-water rugby players)
react with a very profound diving response during apnoea,
while subjects without experience in breath-hold diving
display a less pronounced diving response (3). There was
a strong correlation between the magnitude of the diving
response, when fully established, and the apnoeic
duration. This indicates that the diving response may
reduce the rate of oxygen consumption during apnoeas in
humans.
This study is divided in two parts. The first aim was to
investigate if there was any difference in the
desaturation of arterial haemoglobin resulting from
apnoeas of the same duration in air and with face
immersion in cold water. A more pronounced diving
response at apnoeas with face immersion might reduce the
rate of oxygen consumption, which could be reflected in
a smaller degree of arterial haemoglobin desaturation
during apnoea with face immersion in cold water compared
to during apnoea in air.
The second aim was to study the rate of oxygen uptake
after apnoeas with face immersion in cold water. The
increased oxygen uptake after apnoea could be considered
as a repayment for the reduction in body oxygen stores
during apnoea, and hence reflecting the amount of oxygen
consumed during the apnoea. If the rate of oxygen
consumption during apnoeas is the same as during quiet
breathing the total oxygen uptake during apnoeas and an
associated recovery period would be expected to be equal
to the oxygen uptake before the apnoeas. A reduced
oxygen uptake could indicate a reduced oxygen
consumption during apnoeas.
METHODS
All experiments were conducted in conformity with the
principles of the Declaration of Helsinki and with
approval from the Medical Faculty’s Research Ethics
Committee. Procedures and instruments were demonstrated,
and the volunteers gave their informed consent for
participation. Each subject was told not to
hyperventilate and to make a deep, but not maximal,
inspiration before breath-holding. The subject did not
swallow nor expire and relaxed during breath-holding.
The subject assumed a prone position on a mattress with
the head on a rigid pillow placed above a water
container and the forearms on each side of the
container. Water temperature was 9.5-10.5°C and ambient
air temperature was 22-26°C.
I) 21 healthy subjects of a mean age of 24 yr.
participated. Each subject performed one series of five
apnoeas in air and one series of five apnoeas with face
immersion in cold water. Apnoeas were spaced apart by
two minutes and series by fifteen minutes of rest. The
individual breath-holding times were kept constant at a
submaximal duration in all apnoeas performed by each
subject (average: 126 sec). Half the number of subjects
performed the series with apnoeas in air first. Heart
rate (HR) and arterial blood pressure were continuously
recorded on the middle finger by a photoplethysmometer (Finapres
2300, Ohmeda, Madison, Wisconsin, USA). Skin capillary
blood flow (CBF) in the thumb was continuously measured
with a laser Doppler flowmeter (Advanced Laser Flowmeter
21, Advance Company LTD, Tokyo, Japan). Arterial
haemoglobin oxygen saturation (SaO2) was continuously
measured on the index finger by a pulse oximeter (Biox
3700e, Ohmeda, Madison, Wisconsin, USA). Values were
directly collected in a computer via an A/D-converter.
The continuous recording started 120 sec before the
first apnoea and continued until 120 sec after the last
apnoeic episode. During apnoea in air, the subject had
the face above the water, and during apnoeas with face
immersion the entire face, including the chin and
forehead, was immersed.
The relative change in HR and CBF during apnoea compared
to pre-apnoeic values were calculated for each apnoea.
Control values for SaO2 were calculated from the period
60-30 sec preceding each apnoea. The degree of arterial
haemoglobin desaturation was calculated as the per cent
change in saturation during the first 60 sec after
apnoea, from the control values. The results were
compared between apnoeas in air and apnoeas with face
immersion using paired t-test. The level used for
significance was P<0.05.
II) Five apnoeas with face immersions spaced by 2
min pauses were performed by 8 subjects (mean age: 27 yr.).
HR and SaO2 were continuously measured with the finger
pulse oximeter. CBF in the thumb was continuously
measured with the laser Doppler flowmeter. Values were
directly collected in a computer via an A/D-converter.
Oxygen uptake was recorded with a breath-by-breath
gasanalyser integrated with a computer system (CPX/D
Cardiopulmonary Exercise System, Medical Graphics, MN,
USA). Recordings began 15 min before the first apnoea,
and ceased 30 min after the last apnoea. Venous blood
samples were taken in 5 subjects. Control samples were
collected at rest 10 minutes before apnoeas. Blood
samples were then taken at the beginning and end of each
apnoea and 2, 4, 10 and 30 min after the last apnoea.
The lactate concentration in the blood samples was
analysed immediately in triplicates with a lactate
analyser (Yellow spring institute).
The relative change in HR and CBF during apnoea compared
to pre-apnoeic values were calculated for each apnoea.
Control values of resting oxygen uptake were calculated
from the 15 min of rest before the apnoeas. Recovery
values of oxygen uptake were calculated from onset of
the first apnoea to the end of the 30 min recovery
period after apnoeas. Control values of lactate
concentration, just before the first apnoea, were
compared with peak values after the series of apnoeas.
The values were compared between control and recovery
using paired t-test. The level used for
significance was P<0.05.
RESULTS
Figure 1. Per cent change in heart rate and skin
capillary blood flow during apnoea in air and apnoea
with face immersion. Values are means with SEM for 21
subjects. [Modified from Andersson and Schagatay (1).]
I) During apnoeas in air, the HR-reduction was
7.8% and the CBF-reduction was 37.7% (Fig. 1). The
diving response initiated by both apnoea and face
immersion in cold water was more pronounced (P<0.001).
During apnoeas with face immersion, the HR-reduction was
13.6% and the CBF-reduction was 55.9% (Fig. 1).
Figure 2. Arterial haemoglobin desaturation
during apnoea in air (A) and apnoea with face immersion
(AFI) in one subject breath-holding for 150 sec in both
situations.
Figure 2 shows a typical recording of the continuous
development of SaO2 during apnoeas in air and apnoeas
with face immersion for one subject breath-holding for
exactly 150 sec. As can be seen, SaO2 reaches a lower
level after the apnoea in air than after the apnoea with
face immersion. Mean haemoglobin saturation for all 21
subjects was reduced by 2.7% after apnoeas in air, and
by 1.4% after apnoeas with face immersion (P<0.001).
II) Immediately after each apnoea, during the
first 1-4 breaths, the rate of oxygen uptake was
dramatically increased compared to the rate at rest
before the apnoeas. Within 20 minutes after last apnoea
the oxygen uptake had returned to the control level. In
spite of the dramatic increase in oxygen uptake directly
after the apnoeas, the over-all rate of oxygen uptake
during the period of apnoeas and recovery was reduced by
a mean of 9.0% compared to the rate at rest before the
series (P<0.05). A reduced uptake could be
seen in all subjects except one. Blood lactate increased
from 0.5 mM before the apnoeas to 0.8 mM after the
series (P<0.05).
CONCLUSIONS
After apnpeas with face immersion the arterial
haemoglobin desaturated less than after apnoeas in air,
which suggests that the body oxygen stores were less
depleted after apnoeas with face immersion. In
accordance was the finding of a reduced recovery oxygen
uptake after a series of apnoeas with face immersion
compared to the rate of oxygen uptake before the series.
These results indicate the possibility that the human
diving response may be oxygen conserving. The
bradycardia could result in a lower metabolic demand of
the cardiac muscle, and the pronounced vasoconstriction
could reduce oxygen consumption in some tissues.
The observed increase in lactate concentration after the
series of apnoeas is within the normal variation of
lactate at rest. Åstrand and Rodahl (2) states that
even at rest the blood lactate concentration is about 1
mM. Thus, the increase in this study from 0.5 to 0.8 mM
obviously must be considered as a small increase. To be
taken into account is the fact that all subjects showed
an increase during the BH-series and the decline back to
control level within 30 minutes. Those results imply
that there might be an anaerobic part of the metabolism
during apnoea. However, this is probably not the cause
of the reduced oxygen uptake during the recovery period
as the blood lactate has returned to control level
within the 30 min. The aerobic energy requirements
during removal of the lactic acid (gluconeogensis/oxidation)
after apnoeas would have counteracted the anaerobic
contribution to the reduced aerobic metabolism during
apnoeas and recovery (2).
REFERENCES
1. Andersson, J. and E. Schagatay (1998). Arterial
oxygen desaturation during apnea in humans. Undersea
Hyperbar. Med. 25: 21-25.
2. Åstrand, P.-O. and K. Rodahl (1988). Textbook of
work physiology: Physiological bases of exercise. Third
edition. McGraw-Hill Book Co., Singapore. pp. 295-353.
3. Schagatay, E. and J. Andersson (1998). Diving
response and apneic time in humans. Undersea Hyperbar.
Med. 25: 13-19.
4. Schagatay, E., J. Andersson and B. Holm (1998). The
triggering of the human diving response. This volume.
Published by courtesy of "European
Underwater and Baromedical Society".
Schagatay, E., J. Andersson, and B. Holm. (1998) The
triggering of the human diving response. In: Gennser, M.
(ed.) XXIV Annual Scientific Meeting of the European
Underwater and Baromedical Society. National Defence
Research Establishment, Stockholm, Sweden. FOA Report:
FOA-B--98-00342--721--SE: 88-91.
INTRODUCTION
A series of cardiovascular and respiratory adaptations
permit aquatic air breathers to leave the surface for
extended periods. Among them is the ”diving response”,
which is shared by man. This adaptation, consisting of
selective vasoconstriction and bradycardia, serves to
limit over all oxygen consumption and protect the heart
and brain from asphyxia (2). In humans the response is
induced by breath-holding while immersing the face in
cold water. The magnitude of heart rate reduction is an
often used measure of the magnitude of the diving
response. Trained human divers exhibit a bradycardia of
40-50%, which is in the range of the responses found in
some semiaquatic mammals. As the response in man has
often been reported to reach its maximum in 10°C of
water, it has been concluded that the diving response in
humans is not effective in diving, as most apneic diving
occurs in relatively warm waters (4). The face has been
recognized as the area involved in the triggering of the
response, but the conclusions concerning the location of
the cold receptors involved have varied. While chilling
of the face evokes a parasympathetic effect on the heart,
chilling of other areas of the body are known to trigger
tachycardia (3). The study of the interactions between
the diving response and other cardiovascular reflexes is
limited. The aims of the studies reviewed here were to
further investigate the neural mechanisms responsible
for triggering the human diving response, specifically I)
the influence of air and water temperature (5), II)
the location of the facial cold receptors involved (7)
and III) the interaction between the diving
response and the response to chilling of the arm (6). A
general aim was to make an evaluation of whether the
response is triggered in the human apneic diver.
METHODS
Seventy healthy volunteers participated in these
ethically approved studies. Experi-ments were performed
with the subjects in a prone position, and the orders of
the various exposures were randomized in all tests. The
diving response was elicited by apnea and facial
chilling by cold water bags or by immersion, sometimes
in combination with arm immersion. Cardiovascular and
respiratory parameters were continuously recorded
non-invasively. To evaluate the magnitude of the diving
response the main parameter was the reduction of the
heart rate during apnea from the heart rate obtained
prior to each apnea.
Study I) Twenty three volunteers were exposed for
1 h to 10, 20 and 30°C ambient air, after which they
performed apnea and immersed the face in 10, 20 and 30°C
of water in the climatic chamber.
Study II) The faces of 22 subjects were divided
into six areas of equal size (Fig 2a.), which were
chilled with cold water bags while the subjects
performed apnea. In addition, apnea without immersion
and apnea with full immersion of the face in cold water
were performed.
Study III) While snorkel breathing, nine subjects
performed immersions in 10°C water of 1) the arm, 2)
the face 3) the arm and the face. Sixteen other subjects
performed the same proceedures during simultaneous apnea.
RESULTS
Study I) Both air and water temperatures influenced
the magnitude of the diving response developed. In 10
and 20°C ambient air, there were significant cold
responses at face immersion in 10°C of water, but not
at immersion in 20 or 30°C of water. However, in 30°C
ambient air both 10 and 20°C triggered significant cold
responses (Fig 1., adapted from 5).
Fig 1.
Relationship between ambient air and water temperature
in the triggering of the diving response.
Study II) When the reduction of the heart rate
for chilling of each area was com-pared to the heart
rate reduction at apnea alone, the only significant
increase in heart rate reduction was found when the
forehead or eye regions were chilled. When the responses
from the forehead and eyes were added together they were
equivalent to the response obtained when the whole face
was immersed (Fig 2a., adapted from 7).
Study III) During breathing, simultaneous
immersion of the face and arm in cold water resulted in
a small tachycardia. During apnea, however, chilling of
the arm had no effect on the magnitude of the
bradycardia obtained when the face was immersed into
cold water (Fig 3., adapted from 6).
Fig 3. Heart
rate responses to chilling of face or arm or both, at
eupnea and apnea.
CONCLUSIONS
We concluded that: I) The human diving response
will be triggered also in a warm environment, as long as
the water is colder than the ambient air. Thus the
tropical diver in warm water is likely to develop a
diving response if the ambient air to which the head is
exposed between dives is warmer than the water. II)
The elicitation of the diving response by cold
stimulation is derived from the upper part of the face
innervated by the ophthalmic part of the trigeminal
nerve (forehead and eye area). This will ensure that the
response is triggered during full facial immersion (diving,
Fig 2c.) but not during swimming (Fig 2b). III)
During breathing, the influence from cold stimulation of
the extremity will dominate over the influence from the
stimulation from the upper face, resulting in
tachycardia, while during apnea the influence from the
upper face will abolish the influence from the arm and
produce bradycardia.This suggests that the diving
response is triggered at apneic diving even with
simultaneous body chilling.
The three studies indicate that the sensory inputs serve
well for triggering of the diving response during human
apneic diving and that this possibly oxygen con-serving
response (1) may dominate over other cardiovascular
reflexes during apnea.
REFERENCES
1) Andersson, J. and E.Schagatay (1998). Effects of
the human diving response on oxygen consumption. This
volume.
2) Elsner, R. and B. Gooden (1983). Diving and asphyxia:
a comparative study of animals and man. Physiol. Society
monograph 40. Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge.
3) Frey, M.A.B., E.A. Selm and J.W Walther (1980).
Reflex cardiovascular responses to cold exposure of the
face or foot. Jpn. Heart J. 21: 665-679.
4) Mukhtar, M.R. and J.M. Patrick (1986). Ventilatory
drive during face immersion in man. J. Physiol. 370:
13-24.
5) Schagatay, E. and B. Holm (1996). The effects of
water and ambient air temperatures on human diving
bradycardia. Eur. J. Appl. Occup. Physiol. 73: 1-6.
6) Schagatay, E., J. Andersson and B. Holm (in press).
The conflicting stimuli of chilling the face and the
forearm on cardiovascular regulation. Proceedings from
the International Symposium on Problems with Cold Work,
Nov. 16-20, 1997, Stockholm, Sweden.
7) Schuitema, K.E. and B. Holm (1988). The role of
different facial areas in eliciting human diving
bradycardia. Acta Physiol. Scand. 132: 119-120.
Published by courtesy of "European
Underwater and Baromedical Society".
Andersson, J., E. Schagatay, P. Gustafsson, and H. Örnhagen.
(1998) Cardiovascular effects of “buccal pumping” in
breath-hold divers. In: Gennser, M. (ed.) XXIV Annual
Scientific Meeting of the European Underwater and
Baromedical Society. National Defence Research
Establishment, Stockholm, Sweden. FOA Report: FOA-B--98-00342--721--SE:
103-106.
INTRODUCTION
"Buccal pumping" is a technique by which some
breath-hold divers voluntarily can increase their lung
volume above their normal total lung capacity (TLC).
After a completed maximum inspiration, the diver "gasps"
air into the mouth while the glottis is closed. After
the mouth has been closed, a positive oral pressure is
created by a swallowing manoeuvre, while at the same
time the glottis is opened. Thus, the air is pumped into
the lungs. Thereafter the cycle is repeated until as
much as 1.5 litres has been added to the TLC (7). Buccal
pumping is used by these breath-hold divers to increase
pre-dive lung volume and thereby supposedly also the
theoretical diving depth.
Due to the elastic recoil of the chest wall, the
intrathoracic pressure is increased during
breath-holding at TLC with relaxed respiratory muscles.
This reduces the venous return and thus cardiac output
(4), which causes a transient reduction in arterial
blood pressure (BP) during the first 20 s of
breath-holding (1, 3). This reduction in BP would be
expected to be accentuated by buccal pumping. Fainting
has been reported to occur in association with buccal
pumping by individual divers (personal communications).
This study was designed to elucidate the circulatory
effects of this manoeuvre and to verify the hypothesis
that fainting could be caused by a fall in BP due to the
excessive intrathoracic pressure after buccal pumping.
METHODS
Subjects
This study was approved by the Research Ethics
Committees at the Universities of Göteborg and Lund.
Three subjects (Table 1), capable of buccal pumping at
least 0.5 liters above TLC, volunteered for the study
after being informed about the procedures. They all had
significant experience from breath-hold diving.
Table 1. Subject characteristics.
|
Subject
No.
|
Age
[yr]
|
Height
[cm]
|
Weight
[kg]
|
TLC
[L]
|
TLC
+ Bucc
[L]
|
|
1
|
25
|
184.0
|
72.5
|
5.50
|
6.00
|
|
2
|
25
|
189.0
|
70.4
|
5.54
|
6.54
|
|
3
|
17
|
190.5
|
74.0
|
6.45
|
8.13
|
Procedures
Each subject was sitting in a chair during all
measurements. In order to obtain a standardised
cardiopulmonary situation before each measurement, the
subject stood up and bended knees after which he made a
VC-manoeuvre in the sitting position. One minute of rest
and spontaneous breathing then preceded each measurement.
First a series of measurements at normal TLC was made. A
mouthpiece with a computer regulated on/off valve was
connected to a spirometer (Vicatest 5, Mijnhardts, The
Netherlands). At TLC the subject took the mouthpiece in
his mouth and relaxed his lungs against the closed valve
for measurement of airway pressure. The valve was opened
and 0.5 litres of air was allowed to passively pass out
of the lungs, after which the valve was closed and
relaxation pressure was measured again. The "apnoea"
lasted for about 1 minute during which the lung volume
was gradually lowered by passive exhalation to the
subject's functional residual capacity and then actively
to his residual volume through the valve controlled
mouthpiece. This simulated to some extent a breath-hold
dive with compression of pulmonary gas and elimination
of the high intrathoracic pressure. In each subject 7-8
recordings were made both at TLC and TLC with additional
buccal pumping (TLC + Bucc).
Cardiovascular and pulmonary parameters were
continuously recorded and stored in a computer. Systolic
and diastolic blood pressures were recorded with a
photoplethysmograph (Finapres 2300, Ohmeda, Madison,
Wisconsin), while heart rate was derived from an
EKG-monitor (Micromon 7142, Kontron Instruments, Watford,
U.K.). Arterial haemoglobin oxygen saturation (SaO2) was
recorded with a pulse oximeter (Biox 3700, Ohmeda,
Madison, Wisconsin). Heart rate and blood pressure
values before the manoeuvres during quiet breathing (control)
and at peak inspiration were compared both at TLC and at
TLC+Bucc with a paired t test.
RESULTS
High intrathoracic pressures were produced by the buccal
pumping. At TLC, the average relaxation airway pressure
was 3.1 kPa. After buccal pumping at TLC, the relaxation
airway pressure was increased to 6.1 kPa. For other
pulmonary results, please see Örnhagen et al (7).
Systolic and diastolic blood pressures (BP) were reduced
at both TLC and TLC+Bucc compared to values before the
inspiration (Fig. 1). At TLC, average systolic and
diastolic BP were reduced by 27% and 26%, respectively,
while at TLC+Bucc they were reduced by 49% and 36%,
respectively (Table 2). The lowest BP recorded at
TLC+Bucc in subjects 2 and 3 were 26/24 mmHg and 49/44
mmHg, respectively, while in subject 1 it did not fall
below the value at TLC.
After inspiration to TLC, heart rate increased by 8%.
After buccal pumping heart rate increased by 24%
compared to the control values (Table 2). The SaO2 never
fell below 96% in any subject.
Table 2. Sitting mean heart rate and blood
pressure during control (quiet breathing) and during
apnoea at TLC and TLC+Bucc.
|
|
Heart
rate [bpm]
|
Blood
pressure [mmHg]
|
|
|
Control
|
During
|
Control
|
During
|
|
TLC
|
79
|
85**
|
154/92
|
112/67
|
|
TLC
+ Bucc
|
78
|
97***
|
170/98
|
86/63***
|
Values are means from 3 subjects. Differences compared
to control values are indicated with ** (P<0.01) and
*** (P<0.001), respectively.
Figure 1. Click to enlarge the figure in
a separate window. Arterial blood pressure during
TLC (top) and TLC+Bucc (bottom) in subject 3. Arrows
indicate start of inspiration and beginning of
expiration. A.c. in top figure indicates autocalibration
period of the Finapres.
CONCLUSIONS
During normal breath-holding after an inspiration to
TLC, a brief transient tachycardia and fall in arterial
BP develops (1). However, during continued
breath-holding at TLC this initial drop develops into a
rise in BP within the first 15 sec of apnoea (1, 3). A
similar BP response was observed in this study after
inspiration of TLC. During TLC the pulse pressure is
still 45 mmHg which indicates that venous return was not
completely impeded (Table 2). During buccal pumping the
pulse pressure is dramatically reduced and the systolic
pressure is gradually falling (Table 2, Fig. 1)
indicating that venous return was impeded to a great
extent by the high intrathoracic pressure. If the high
intrathoracic pressure had been kept longer than 15 s as
if a person had practised breath-holding after buccal
pumping on land it is most likely that syncope had been
the result. The very rapid gain in BP when intrathoracic
pressure is relieved (Fig. 1) indicate that syncope from
buccal pumping is a risk if the diver remains at the
surface and not when diving, because already at 2 m
depth the pulmonary "over-inflation" is
eliminated due to compression of pulmonary gas.
Inspired and held lung volume during apnoea has been
shown to affect the human diving response (i.e.,
bradycardia and vasoconstriction) by both mechanical and
pulmonary stretch receptor effects (1). The mechanical
effects are most pronounced in the beginning of
breath-holding and similar to the effects observed in
this study. The stretch receptor effects are probably
effective during the entire apnoea if the lung volume is
kept constant. It is not clear how these considerably
high intrathoracic pressures affect the high pressure
sensitive pulmonary J-receptors (2). Neither is it
certain that the pulmonary J-receptors, if stimulated,
affect the circulation in the normal way (i.e., reflex
cardiac slowing and vasodilatation) upon stimulation
during TLC+Bucc (5). Also, in our experiments the
influence from pulmonary stretch receptors was most
likely reduced towards the end of the apnoea when the
lung volume and pressure were small.
The BP recorded during quiet breathing in the sitting
young subjects were somewhat high and probably reflects
the normal cardiovascular response to a new and
demanding situation for the subjects. Digital artery
blood pressure values recorded with the Finapres have
also been reported to be slightly higher than brachial
artery measurements (6).
Our results support the suggestion that reported cases
of fainting among breath-hold divers performing buccal
pumping, could have been caused by the excessive
increase in intrathoracic pressure. The most dramatic
reductions in BP observed at peak buccal pumping
indicate that loss of consciousness must be considered
as a risk, especially if the diver remains at the
surface. One should also bear in mind that the levels of
buccal pumping performed by the subjects in this study
were not maximal since avoidance of syncope was pursued
and it was a demanding protocol with several
repetitions. In an authentic diving situation were
buccal pumping is performed to a maximal or near maximal
level, the cardiovascular effects are probably even more
pronounced.
REFERENCES
1. Andersson, J. and E. Schagatay (1998). Effects of
lung volume and involuntary breathing movements on the
human diving response. Eur. J. Appl. Physiol. 77:19-24.
2. Kaufman, M.P., G.A. Iwamoto, J.H. Ashton and S.S.
Cassidy (1982). Responses to inflation of vagal
afferents with endings in the lung of dogs. Circ. Res.
51:525-531.
3. Kawakami, Y., B.H. Natelson and A.B. DuBois (1967).
Cardiovascular effects of face immersion and factors
affecting diving reflex in man. J. Appl. Physiol.
23:964-970.
4. Linér, M.H. (1994). Cardiovascular and pulmonary
responses to breath-hold diving in humans. Acta Physiol.
Scand. 151(Suppl 620):1-32.
5. Shepherd, J.T. (1981). The lungs as receptor sites
for cardiovascular regulation. Circulation 63:1-10.
6. Stroud, M.A., D.P. James, D. Railton and P.J. Sowood
(1994). Digital and brachial artery blood pressure
measurements during peripheral, cold-induced
vasoconstriction. Eur. J. Appl. Physiol. 68:134-138.
7. Örnhagen, H., E. Schagatay, J. Andersson, E.
Bergsten, P. Gustafsson and S. Sandström (1998)
Mechanisms of "buccal pumping" and its
pulmonary effects. This volume.
Published by courtesy of "European
Underwater and Baromedical Society".
Schagatay,
E., J. Andersson, and B. Holm. (1997) The conflicting
stimuli of chilling of the face and the forearm on
cardiovascular regulation. In: Holmér, I., and K.
Kuklane (eds.) International Symposia on Problems with
Cold Work. National Institute for Working Life,
Stockholm, Sweden. Arbete och Hälsa 18: 178-181.
Congress
Abstracts
de
Bruijn, R., Richardson, M., Schagatay, E. (2003) The
function of the human diving response in the immersed
diver. Annual Meeting of the European Underwater
and Baromedical Society, Copenhagen, Denmark.
Background:
Much previous research has used apneic face immersion as
a model for studying the diving response and its
oxygen-conserving effect, however there are few direct
comparisons to apneic face immersion with the body
immersed. Therefore, it is not settled if the oxygen
conserving effect revealed in the dry-body model
persists in the immersed diver. In this study we
compared the diving response and its effect on arterial
oxygen saturation between apnea in horizontal dry-body
and immersed-body conditions.
Methods:
Twelve individually determined near-maximal apneas of
the same duration were completed by 17 healthy untrained
subjects at rest. Three apneas in each of four
categories were performed: dry-body apnea (DA), dry-body,
face-immersion apnea (DFIA), immersed-body apnea (IA),
and immersed-body, face-immersion apnea (IFIA), in a
weighted order. For the face and body immersions, mean
water temperature (± SD) was 23.1 ±0.12oC
and mean air temperature was 23.3 ±0.32oC.
Heart rate and arterial haemoglobin saturation were
recorded non-invasively with a pulse oximeter.
Results:
The diving response was similar for both the dry-body
and the immersed body-categories. In all 4 categories
the heart rate was reduced. The heart rate reduction in
DFIA and IFIA categories was more pronounced than in the
DA and IA categories. Heart rate reduction during DA and
DFIA was 10% (±1.6) and 18% (±2.8) respectively (P<0.01),
while heart rate reduction during IA and IFIA was 9% (±2.6)
and 18% (±3.1) respectively (P<0.01).
In both the DFIA and IFIA categories there was
less desaturation compared to the DA and IA categories
(DA vs. DFIA P<0.001,
IA vs. IFIA P<0.05).
Conclusion:
Face immersion enhances the apneic diving response both
in the dry- and immersed-body conditions, and is
associated with a less pronounced arterial oxygen
desaturation. We conclude that the immersed diver may
benefit from an oxygen conserving diving response. This
study also shows that the dry-body model can be useful
for studying the diving response.
Robert
de Bruijn,
Matt Richardson, Ulrica Milling, Hanna Lemon, Erika
Schagatay. (2004). Erythropoeitin production as a
result of repeated apneas. Annual meeting of the
European Undersea and Baromedical Society, Ajaccio,
Corsica, France.
Background:
It has been known for decades that high altitude hypoxia
will lead to increased erythropoiesis. Hypoxia in mainly
the kidney results in an increased production of
erythropoietin (EPO) stimulating erythropoiesis. High
altitude natives display a higher haemoglobin
concentration than sea level residents, which in turn
increase their haemoglobin concentration as part of the
adaptation to altitude. Another group of humans exposed
to hypoxia is apneic divers, which may endure transient
acute hypoxia, spaced by periods of normal breathing. We
recently found higher haemoglobin levels in elite apneic
divers, compared to groups of elite skiers and untrained
subjects, suggesting that apnea training may induce
erythropoiesis in humans. It is well known that diving
mammals display high haemoglobin concentrations, and the
beneficial effects are obvious: A larger oxygen store
before diving prolongs the aerobic dive limit, and a
higher haemoglobin concentration may speed up recovery
after apneas and act as a buffer against acidosis during
the dive. Although our group comparisons reveal a higher
haemoglobin concentration in divers, it cannot be
determined whether this is a training effect or
genetically determined i.e. if individuals with higher
concentrations of haemoglobin are more prone to take up
apneic diving.
Methods:
To investigate if apnea training can induce EPO
production, 5 previously untrained volunteers (3 men and
2 women, mean age±SD
28 ±5.5
years) performed 15 maximal apneas in a horizontal
position in air. The apneas were grouped in 3 series of
5 apneas and spaced by 2 minutes of which 1 minute was
spent slightly hyperventilating, to produce apneas
sufficiently long to induce hypoxia. Series were spaced
by 10 minutes resting periods. To determine EPO levels,
venous blood samples were taken before apneas and
directly after the last apnea series, followed by
samples 1, 2, 3 and 5 hours after the apneas.
Results:
Mean baseline EPO before the apneas was 10.2 U/L. In all
subjects EPO levels increased during the 5 hours period
after the apneas. The time for EPO-peak values were
different among individuals. The mean peak value
occurred after 3 h, where the mean increase was 12 % of
the pre apnea reference value.
Conclusion:
The results suggest that apnea induced intermittent
hypoxia could lead to increased erythropoiesis. The
evaluation of these findings in a larger group of
subjects, including measurements of the individual
circadian variations in EPO production, is in progress.
Robert
de Bruijn, Matt Richardson,
Helena Haughey
, HC Holmberg, Glenn Björklund, and
Erika Schagatay
(2004). Hemoglobin levels in elite divers, elite skiers
and untrained humans. Annual
meeting of the European Undersea and Baromedical Society,
Ajaccio, Corsica, France.
Background:
In diving mammals the oxygen storage capacity plays an
important role in determining aerobic dive duration.
This is therefore also likely to be of vital importance
for performance in human apneic divers. In endurance
athletes, oxygen carrying capacity is an important
factor for maintaining a high oxygen supply to the
working muscle. The amount of oxygen stored in the blood
is largely determined by the hemoglobin concentration (Hb).
Increased circulating Hb would prolong apneas by
improving the gas storage and transportation capacity of
the blood. This would increase the available oxygen
during apnea, improve the CO2 buffering
capacity and provide faster recovery from hypoxia and
hypercapnia during breathing intervals. We therefore
aimed to investigate Hb levels in elite divers, compared
to non divers and non diving endurance athletes.
Methods:
We compared the Hb in 3 groups of male subjects: elite
apneic divers, elite cross-country skiers and untrained
subjects. The 13 apneic divers were all registered
competitors for a world apnea championship, and trained
apnea (mean+SE) for 7.3 ±1.2 h/week and related
physical activities for 8.9 ±1.9 h/week. The 13
cross-country skiers were all members of the Swedish
national team for their respective age groups and
trained 13.5+1.0 hours per week of ski training
or related physical activities, and were inexperienced
in apneic diving. The 23 untrained subjects had little
or no experience in breath-holding and none was a
competitive athlete in any sport. The mean age for
divers was 35±4 years, for skiers 20±1 years and for
untrained subjects 29±1 years, weight and height were
similar for all groups. After a period of 20 min of
horizontal rest in order to account for posture-related
effects on filtration, venous blood samples, or
capillary samples obtained by finger puncture, were
drawn and analysed for Hb using standard
Hemocue-equipment.
Results:
The apneic divers had higher Hb than both the untrained
subjects (P<0.05) and the skiers (P<0.01). The Hb
did not differ between the untrained subjects and the
skiers (Figure).
Conclusion:
Apneic divers displayed a higher Hb than endurance
athletes and untrained subjects. We suggest that the
specific apnea training, involving hypoxic periods, may
lead to increased erythropoiesis, in a similar way as
during high altitude exposure. The result in skiers is
in accordance with earlier findings in endurance
athletes, and may reflect that the blood volume, not
specifically the Hb, has increased.
Richardson,
M., Holmberg, H.-C., de Bruijn, R., Björklund, G.,
Haughey, H., Schagatay, E. (2004) Hemoglobin
concentration after serial apneas in divers, skiers and
untrained humans. 7th Scandiavian Congress on Medicine
and Science in Sports, Stockholm, Sweden.
Introduction:
In
addition to the human cardiovascular ‘diving response’,
i.e., bradycardia and peripheral vasoconstriction during
apnea, recent studies have shown that spleen contraction
also occurs during repeated apneas. This latter
response may serve to expel erythrocytes into the
circulation to promote gas transportation. Both
responses are highly individual, and while the
cardiovascular diving response is known to be more
pronounced after apnea training, no study has previously
adressed the possible training effect on the spleen
related hematological response. Spleen contraction has
also been observed as a result of physical exercise, and
its possible effects would be to increase aerobic
capacity. The aim of the present investigation was to
study the hematological responses to serial apneas
performed during rest by elite apneic divers, by elite
cross-country skiers and by untrained subjects.
Methods:
After 20 min of rest, 78 subjects (32 untrained subjects,
13 elite skiers, and 33 elite apneic divers) of both
sexes performed three maximal apneas, each spaced by a
two minute normal breathing interval. Blood samples were
taken before, directly after, and 10 minutes after the
apneic series and analyzed for haemoglobin (Hb)
concentration.
Results:
All groups responded to maximal apneas with an increase
in hemoglobin concentration, which had disappeared after
10 min of recovery. The increase in hemoglobin
concentration was more pronounced in the apneic divers
(4g/L) than in skiers (3g/L) and untrained subjects
(2g/L; P
< 0.05). All groups prolonged their apneic times
through the series, but the increase was most evident
for the divers versus both the skiers (P
< 0.05) and untrained subjects
(P
< 0.01).
Conclusions:
Significant increases in Hb and Hct values occur
immediately after a maximal apnea series, followed by a
return towards baseline values after 10 minutes,
regardless of physical activity level or training type.
These increases are likely due to spleen contraction as
demonstrated in previous research. However, of the
three groups the elite apnea divers were responding most
strongly. The results suggest that these responses could
be more pronounced as a result of apnea training in
comparison to high-intensity aerobic training.
Richardson,
M., Haughey, H., de Bruijn, R., Andersson, J., Schagatay,
E. (2003) Hematological Response pattern associated with
maximal-duration Apnea series in untrained subjects.
Annual Meeting of the European Underwater and
Baromedical Society, Copenhagen, Denmark.
Background:
In
addition to the human cardiovascular ‘diving response’,
i.e., bradycardia and peripheral vasoconstriction during
apnea, recent studies have shown that spleen contraction
also occurs during repeated apneas.
This latter response may serve to expel
erythrocytes into the circulation to promote gas
transportation. However,
prospective changes in blood parameters after repeated
apneas have yet to be systematically described.
As is the case with diving response parameters,
some individuals may have stronger haematological
changes from performing apneic series than others. These
variations need to be considered in future studies of
the function of the spleen and blood components during
apnea. The
present study was aimed to describe the haematological
response pattern associated with repeated maximal apneas
in healthy non-divers.
Methods:
After 20 min of rest, 46 healthy untrained subjects of
both sexes performed three maximal apneas, spaced by two
minutes rest and normal breathing. Blood samples were
taken before, within 1 minute after, and 10 minutes
after the apneic series and analyzed for changes in
haemoglobin (Hb) concentration and hematocrit (Hct).
Results:
Pre-apnea Hb concentration (mean±SE) was normally
distributed (147.1±1.6 g/L).
An increase of 2.1±0.3% in the Hb value was seen
immediately post-series, followed by a decrease from
this value of 1.8±0.3% at 10 minutes post-series.
Pre-apnea hematocrit (41.2±0.6 percent) showed a
similar increase immediately post-series of 3.2±0.8%
followed by a decrease of 1.6±0.4% from this value at
10 minutes post-series.
Classifying subjects as strong responders (above
75th percentile) and weak responders (below
25th percentile) resulted in mean increases
in Hb and Hct above pre-apneic values of 4.7±0.4% and
7.1±2.1%, respectively for strong responders, and -0.5±0.4
and 0.5±0.6, respectively for weak responders.
Conclusion:
Significant increases in Hb and Hct values occur
immediately after a maximal apneic series, followed by a
return towards baseline values after 10 minutes.
These increases may be due to the spleen
contraction as demonstrated in previous research.
Furthermore, some subjects appear to respond more
strongly than others, and pre-screening for these types
of responders may be judicious in future testing.
The mechanism(s) underlying the strength of these
haematological responses warrants further investigation.
Schagatay, E., E. Rünow, and J. Andersson. (2001)
Diving response and arterial desaturation during
exercise and apnea. In: XXXIV International Congress of
Physiological Sciences. International Union of
Physiological Sciences, Christchurch, New Zealand.
Schagatay, E., J. Andersson, and B. Nielsen. (2001) Does
facial chilling augment the hematocrit increase seen at
human apneic diving? In: International Thermal
Physiology Symposium. IUPS Commission on Thermal
Physiology, Wollongong, Australia.
Andersson, J., J. Larsson, and E. Schagatay. (2000)
Yoga-breathing, apnea, and alveolar gas exchange.
Undersea Hyperb Med 27 (Suppl.).
BACKGROUND:
Competitive breath-hold divers use different techniques
to prepare both mentally and physically before diving.
Long periods of slow, deep breathing have been reported
to precede diving in elite breath-hold divers. We
investigated how a specific, yoga inspired, pre-dive
ventilation used by some Swedish elite breath-hold
divers affect alveolar gas exchange and apneic ability.
METHODS: Four divers experienced in using
yoga-techniques before breath-holding volunteered. They
performed four breath-holds with face immersion in 10°C
water during prone rest, spaced by >20 min of rest.
The two last breath-holds were preceded by two 3-min
periods of “yoga-breathing”, i.e., slow and deep
breathing, separated by 5 min of rest. Apnea followed
the end of the second yoga-breathing period. The apneic
times in all four breath-holds were predetermined and
kept equal. Respiratory and cardiovascular parameters
were recorded non-invasively. The two phases of the
apnea were identified by recording the thoracic
movements and detecting the onset of involuntary
breathing movements triggered by the increase in PaCO2.
RESULTS: The ventilation increased from 11.4
l*min-1 before the control apneas to 23.3 l*min-1 during
the yoga-breathing (P<0.01). The pre-apneic
PETCO2-values were lowered from 4.74 to 3.78 mmHg after
yoga-breathing (P<0.05), and the RER were 1.03
and 1.44, respectively (P<0.05). The mean
breath-holding time of the apneas was 161 s, and the
duration of the first, “easy going phase” was 102 s
in the control apneas. After yoga-breathing the duration
of the “easy going phase” had dramatically increased
(P<0.01), as no involuntary breathing
movements appeared during the subsequent apneas.
CONCLUSIONS: The yoga-breathing performed by
these divers was clearly a hyperventilation with
profound physiological effects, and may be a risk factor
in competitive apneic diving. This prolonged
hyperventilation probably affects not only the CO2
stores of fast-equilibrating tissues, i.e., lungs and
blood, but also that of slow tissues, i.e., muscles.
Published by courtesy of "Undersea and
Hyperbaric Medicine".
Andersson, J., P. Tomberg, and E. Schagatay. (2000)
Influence of volition on the human diving response.
Undersea Hyperb Med 27 (Suppl.).
BACKGROUND:
Some diving mammals have been shown to display cortical
influence on the magnitude of the heart rate reduction
during diving. Psychophysiological investigations show
that the human diving response can be augmented by fear
and attenuated if subjects perform mental arithmetic.
Our aim was to study the possible volitional control of
the human diving response by short and long apneas.
METHODS: The volunteers were twelve healthy
subjects with a mean age of 25 yr, including four under
water rugby players. Each subject performed two series
of three apneas with face immersion in 10°C water,
during prone rest. Three apneas were of a maximal
duration while three were of a fixed, sub-maximal
duration. Apneas were spaced by 10 min pauses. The
series were randomly ordered. Mean arterial pressure (MAP),
heart rate (HR) and skin capillary blood flow (SkBF)
were recorded non-invasively. Cardiovascular data from
the periods 90-30 sec before apnea and 30-60 sec during
apnea were compared for effects of apneas. The responses
to short and long duration apneas were compared using
paired t-test.
RESULTS: Mean breath-holding times were 61 and
151 sec in the two series. The HR and SkBF reductions
did not differ between the short and long apneas, but
the increase in MAP was higher during the long apneas (P<0.05).
The MAP increased from 99 and 103 mmHg before (NS), to
110 and 117 mmHg during the short and long apneas (P<0.001).
CONCLUSION: The HR and SkBF responses during
apnea were not affected by anticipation. However, the
higher MAP during the maximum duration apneas suggests a
more pronounced selective vasoconstriction in some
tissues during the long apneas. We conclude that there
may be a cortical influence on components of the human
diving response in humans, expressed as a stronger
response during maximum duration apneas.
Published by courtesy of "Undersea and
Hyperbaric Medicine".
Andersson,
J., E. Schagatay, and B. Nielsen. (1999) Effects of
apneas on alveolar gas exchange. Undersea Hyperb Med 26
(Suppl): 29.
INTRODUCTION:
The breath-by-breath ventilation (end-tidal carbon
dioxide and oxygen [PETCO2/O2] and tidal volume [VT])
during recovery following apneas were investigated.
METHODS: Five maximal duration apneas with face
immersions spaced by 2 min pauses were performed by 3
subjects. Apneas were performed during prone rest after
a deep inspiration. PETCO2/O2 and VT were recorded with
a breath-by-breath flow- and gasanalyzer. Average values
from the first apnea are presented.
RESULTS: The breath-holding time was 168 s. The
PETCO2 and PETO2 in the first expiration after apneas
were 40.3 and 81.3 mmHg, respectively. After 5-10 s of
breathing the PETCO2 had decreased to 27.4 mmHg, while
the PETO2 increased to 126.9 mmHg. After 30 s the PETCO2
and PETO2 were 36.6 and 115.1 mmHg, respectively. I.e.,
the PETCO2 values produced an approximately U-shaped
curve during the initial 20-30 s of recovery. This was
reflected by an inverse shape of the PETO2 curve. The
average VT during the initial 15 s after apnea was 2.2
liters and gradually decreased so that after 30 s the VT
was 1.1 liters.
CONCLUSIONS: During apnea there is a continuous
O2 uptake from the lungs to the blood. However, it has
been shown that a large portion of the CO2 does not
enter the alveoli during normobaric apnea, but is
buffered in the body, particularly in distal parts of
the body, due to the reduced cardiac output (1). This is
reflected by the roughly U-shaped curve of the PETCO2
values during the initial 20-30 s of recovery. In the
first maximal expiration following the apnea the total
lung CO2 content is expelled. The following breaths have
lower PETCO2 values. As the cardiac output increases the
distal CO2 pools are unloaded to the lungs and the
PETCO2 increases again. Similarly, the increased cardiac
output and perfusion of the lungs with blood of a low O2
content, causes reduced PETO2 values later in the
recovery period. This could be considered as a
ventilation-perfusion mismatch in the early recovery
period.
REFERENCE: 1. Linér MH. Cardiovascular and
pulmonary responses to breath-hold diving in humans.
Acta Physiol Scand 1984; 151 (Suppl 620):1-32.
Published by courtesy of "Undersea
and Hyperbaric Medicine".
Schagatay, E., and J. Andersson. (1999) The respiratory,
circulatory and hematological effects of repeated apneas
in humans. Undersea Hyperb Med 26 (Suppl): 29-30.
BACKGROUND:
The natural way to dive for animals and man is to
perform serial dives, with durations and surface
intervals suitable to allow enough time at the
profitable depth. Therefore, a relevant aspect of apneic
diving physiology is to study the effect of one dive
upon another. This is a preliminary report of three
studies from our laboratory concerning the short term
effects of serial apneas.
METHODS: 65 young, healthy non divers
participated. Diving was simulated by apnea and facial
immersion (AFI) in 10°C water by subjects at prone
rest. Maximal duration apneas were spaced by 2 min of
breathing. Series I (n=7) consisted of 12 AFI,
series II (n=41) and III (n=17) of 5 AFI.
Subjects were told to avoid hyperventilation and to
perform apnea after a deep but not maximal inspiration.
Recordings were done using standard, non invasive
methods. Blood samples were drawn from a venous catheter
in study III.
RESULTS: Respiratory effects: Apneic
duration increased until AFI6 (I). The
physiological breaking point (determined by the PaCO2)
was delayed until AFI3 (II; III). No
difference was found between the five AFI in pre-apneic
lung volume or end-tidal CO2 of the last breath before
apnea (III). Circulatory effects:
The cardiovascular “diving response” was attenuated
by the repetition (I-III). The reduction
of heart rate and skin capillary blood flow, and the
increase of mean arterial blood pressure from control
were highest during AFI 1 or 2 (I-III),
and the responses stabilized after 6 apneas (I).
Hematological effects: Hematocrit (Hct) and
hemoglobin concentration (Hb) increased over AFI1-3, and
had returned to control value ten minutes after the
apneas (III). No change in the total protein
content was observed.
CONCLUSIONS: Prolonged apneic duration by
repetition of apneas was caused by both physiological
and psychological factors. The physiological mechanisms
involved in these studies were not increased lung volume,
decreased PACO2 by hyperventilation or an increase of
the diving response. Among the possible causes, a
reversible increase in the blood gas storage capacity by
increased Hct and Hb over series of dives could be
considered. This change may be caused by splenic
contraction.
Published by courtesy of "Undersea
and Hyperbaric Medicine".
Andersson, J., E. Schagatay, and G. Biasoletto-Tjellström.
(1999) The hypercapnic ventilatory response before and
after a breath holding series. In: Shupak, A., R.
Lincoln, and Y. Grossman (eds.) XXV Annual Scientific
Meeting of the European Underwater and Baromedical
Society, Haifa and Eilat, Israel: 232.
Introduction
The mechanisms behind the "short-term training
effect", the increase in breath holding time (BHT)
observed when apneas are repeated with short intervals,
have not been elucidated. Analysis of the appearance of
the "physiological breaking point", reached at
a critical PaCO2 level, reveals that both
physiological and psychological factors are responsible
for this effect. One possible contributing factor could
be a reduced CO2 chemosensitivity caused by
repeated apneas.
Methods
Seven subjects volunteered (6 M/1 F; mean age 26 yr;
height: 183 cm; weight: 77 kg). None of the subjects was
a trained apneic diver. All subjects performed five
apneas with face immersion in 10°C water spaced by two
minutes pauses. The hypercapnic ventilatory response (HCVR)
was tested with the rebreathing method of Read (1967)
after normal breathing (control) and one minute after
the series of apneas. The control HCVR test was
performed either 30 min before (n=4) or 30 min after
(n=3) the series of apneas. The initial gas mixture
consisted of 7% CO2, 50% O2 and
43% N2. Respiratory variables and end-tidal
gas pressures were continuously recorded. The CO2
chemosensitivity was expressed as the slope of the HCVR
curve (dVE.dPETCO2-1).
Results
The mean BHT increased from 111 s in the first apnea to
151 s in the fifth apnea (P<0.05). Five
subjects (mean BHT: 150 s) had a decreased HCVR after
the series of apneas, while two subjects (mean BHT: 85
s) had an increased response. The average values for all
subjects were 2.42 and 2.07 liters.min-1.mm
Hg CO2-1 for the control and the
post apnea HCVR, respectively (NS). For the 5 subjects
with a reduced post apnea HCVR, the mean values were
2.52 and 1.66 liters.min-1.mm
Hg CO2-1 (P<0.05), and
for the 2 subjects with an increased response, they were
2.18 and 3.11 liters.min-1.mm
Hg CO2-1 (NS).
Conclusions
We conclude that a reduced CO2
chemosensitivity could be one contributing factor to the
short-term training effect of repeated apneas.
Published
by courtesy of "European Underwater and
Baromedical Society".
Schagatay,
E., and J. Andersson. (1998) The short term training
effect of repeated apneas on haematocrit in humans. In:
Gennser, M. (ed.) XXIV Annual Scientific Meeting of the
European Underwater and Baromedical Society. National
Defence Research Establishment, Stockholm, Sweden. FOA
Report: FOA-B--98-00342--721--SE: 112.
INTRODUCTION
In some marine mammals, the spleen is believed to serve
as a dynamic red blood cell reservoir, causing elevated
haematocrit and haemoglobin concentrations during diving.
A 20% decrease in splenic volume in working ama-divers
after a three hours diving shift was found with an
ultrasonic scanner (Hurford et al 1990). This was
accompanied by a 10% increase in haematocrit (Hct) and
haemoglobin concentration (Hb). Haemoconcentration due
to diuresis was not excluded. Our aim was to investigate
the effects of repeated breath-holds (BH) on Hct and Hb,
to reveal if any observed change is reversible.
METHODS
Ten volunteers performed five maximal duration BH:s with
face immersion in 10°C water. BH:s were performed in a
prone position and spaced by 2 min of rest. Venous blood
samples were taken immediately before the first BH
(Sample no. 1), and directly after BH no. 1, 3 and 5
(Sample no. 2-4). Samples were also taken 3, 10 and 20
minutes after the BH-series (Sample no. 5-7).
RESULTS
Hct and Hb increased over the BH-series. Twenty minutes
after the series, values had decreased from to the level
before the BH-series.
Table 1. Hb and Hct before, during and after the
BH-series.
|
No.
|
1
|
2
|
3
|
4
|
5
|
6
|
7
|
|
Hb
g/dl
|
14.4±0.4
|
14.6±0.3
|
14.8±0.4
|
14.9±0.3
|
14.8±0.3
|
14.4±0.3
|
14.2±1.0
|
|
Hct
%
|
37.6±1.3
|
39.2±0.9
|
40.3±0.9
|
39.8±0.8
|
40.0±0.8
|
39.0±2.6
|
38.2±1.1
|
Values
are means±SEM, n=10.
CONCLUSIONS
Reversible increases in Hb and Hct occur during BH in
man. This indicates that the increases in Hb and Hct
found by Hurford et al (1990) were probably not only
caused by increased diuresis, and that a possible cause
could be the observed splenic contraction.
Reference
Hurford, W.E. Hong, S.K., Park, Y.S., et al. Splenic
contraction during breath-hold diving in the Korean ama.
J Appl Physiol 69: 932-936, 1990.
Published by courtesy of "European
Underwater and Baromedical Society".
Gustafsson, P.M., S. Sandström, J. Andersson, E.
Schagatay, and H. Örnhagen. (1998) Radiografisk
beskrivning av hur överfyllning av lungorna åstadkoms
med s k "buccal pumping" hos andhållnings-dykare.
In: Svenska Läkaresällskapets Rikstämma, Göteborg,
Sweden.
Örnhagen, H., E. Schagatay, J. Andersson, E. Bergsten,
and P. Gustafsson. (1998) "Grodandning" eller
"buccal pumping", en ny riskfaktor inom
sportdykning? In: Svenska Läkaresällskapets Rikstämma,
Göteborg, Sweden.
Andersson, J., and E. Schagatay. (1997) Arterial
hemoglobin desaturation during apneas in humans. In: The
Society for Experimental Biology Annual Meeting,
Canterbury, England: 53.
Andersson, J., E. Schagatay, and B. Holm. (1997)
Cardiovascular responses to arm and face immersion in
cold water during apnea. In: XXXIII International
Congress of Physiological Sciences. International Union
of Physiological Sciences, St. Petersburg, Russia:
PO58.30.
Andersson,
J., and E. Schagatay. (1996) Effects of lung volume and
involuntary breathing movements on the human diving
response. The Physiologist 39: A28.
Schagatay, E., and J. Andersson. (1996) Effects of
training on diving response and time in humans. The
Physiologist 39: A28.
Other
Papers
Andersson,
J., and E. Schagatay. (1996) Människan som fridykare
(In Swedish). UVM - Undervattensmagasinet 1: 46-47.
Artikeln är utlagd i pdf-format. Läs om pdf här.
Schagatay,
E., B. Holm, and J. Andersson. (1995) Dykning: Effekter
av träning på människans dyktid och dykrespons (In
Swedish). Svensk Idrottsforskning 3: 45-47.
|